Best Thrifting In Payson
If you're staying at Eagle's Nest Payson, nestled along the scenic Payson Golf Course, you're perfectly positioned to explore the town's charming thrift stores. Whether you're hunting for vintage treasures, unique home décor, or supporting local causes, Payson's thrift scene offers something for everyone. Here's a curated guide to some of the best thrift shops near your rental:
🛍️ Top Thrift Stores Near Eagle's Nest Payson
1. New Beginnings – The Nook
Address: 408 W Main St, Payson, AZ
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 9:30 AM – 4:00 PM
Phone: (928) 474-7466
Highlights: The Nook is renowned for its clean, well-organized environment and friendly volunteers, providing a welcoming atmosphere for shoppers. Patrons often praise the store for its excellent prices and the variety of treasures available. Proceeds from The Nook support New Beginnings' mission to assist mothers in need, making each purchase a contribution to a meaningful cause
2. St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store
Address: 1006 S Beeline Hwy, Payson, AZ
Hours: Friday–Saturday, 10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Phone: (928) 474-4476
Highlights: Operated entirely by dedicated volunteers, the store sells a variety of new and gently used household items at fair prices. All proceeds from donations and merchandise sales directly support the Rim Country Food Bank, which provides approximately 25,000 food boxes annually to families in need. The coolest part? It’s actually a “shopping mall” with 3 separate quaint buildings each housing different categories of items.
3. Trinkets & Treasures
Address: 512 W Main St, Payson, AZ
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 9:30 AM – 4:00 PM
Phone: (928) 474-3205
Highlights: A fine resale shop benefiting the Payson Senior Center, featuring a curated selection of items in a boutique setting.
4. Humane Society Resale Store & Vintage Boutique
Address: 510 W Main St, Payson, AZ
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 9:00 AM – 4:15 PM
Phone: (928) 468-6419
Highlights: Proceeds support the Humane Society of Central Arizona. Find vintage items, furniture, and more while contributing to animal welfare.
5. Time Out Thrift Shop
Address: 244 E Hwy 260, Payson, AZ
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Phone: (928) 474-3989
Highlights: Supporting the Time Out Shelter, this shop offers a variety of second-hand items, with proceeds aiding victims of domestic violence.
6. U-Turn for Christ Thrift Store
Address: 501 W Main St, Payson, AZ
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Phone: (928) 978-6381
Highlights: U-Turn for Christ Thrift is more than just a secondhand shop; it's a vital part of a faith-based initiative aimed at transforming lives affected by addiction. The store supports the U-Turn for Christ Arizona program, a residential Christian discipleship ministry dedicated to helping individuals break free from the bondage of drug and alcohol addiction through biblical-centered recovery. The thrift store offers a diverse selection of gently used items, including clothing, housewares, books, DVDs, and furniture. Customers have praised the store for its clean, well-lit environment and friendly, cheerful staff. One visitor noted the variety of choices and the positive atmosphere, emphasizing the good feeling that comes from supporting such a worthwhile program. You’ll be happy to know that Eagle’s Nest has donated to U-Turn’s program via their community service program. We’ve been happy to have many of their individuals at our property helping firewise the front yard hill and paint the covered parking structure.
All these stores are within a short drive from Eagle's Nest Payson, making it easy to plan a leisurely day of thrifting. Main Street and Beeline Highway are the primary areas where these shops are concentrated, offering a convenient route for your shopping adventure.
🏡 About Eagle's Nest Payson
Eagle's Nest Payson is a charming rental property located along the picturesque Payson Golf Course. With its serene setting and proximity to local attractions, it's the perfect base for exploring all that Payson has to offer, including its delightful thrift stores.
Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just looking for a unique souvenir, Payson's thrift stores offer a treasure trove of possibilities. Enjoy your stay at Eagle's Nest Payson and happy thrifting!